Detail from The Martyrdom of Saint Andrew giving to Georgetown University Library


Library Associates Newsletter
Summer 2004, Newsletter 72

Father Greaton's Bible

Father Joseph Greaton, S.J., the founder of Old Saint Joseph's Church in Philadelphia, is rightly regarded as one of the most important of the Jesuit missionaries in colonial America. Born in 1679, Greaton is recorded as being in Maryland in 1722. Shortly thereafter he transferred his activities to Philadelphia, where he served almost all the rest of his life. While the Bible he used might not be as exciting as the relic of a major saint, it is worthy of notice, not least in Philadelphia.

The first tantalizing mention of "Father Greaton's Bible" is found in an unpublished typescript history of the early Pennsylvania missions by Father Robert Parsons, S.J., written at the time he served as a curate at Old Saint Joseph's in the 1950s. Unfortunately, Father Parsons neglected to describe the Bible in an easily identifiable way, and with his death in 1963 the subject passed into obscurity. He did note, however, that he had seen the Bible in the collections of the Woodstock College Library. At that time Woodstock was the seminary for the Maryland Province of the Society of Jesus, and its library, which now runs to nearly 200,000 volumes, even then had a collection of over 10,000 early and rare books. Mercifully, not so very many of these were, or are, Bibles.

Old St. Joseph's Catholic Church

Old St. Joseph's Catholic Church, gateway from Willings Alley. Courtesy of Old St. Joseph's Archives; photo by Laird Bindrim, St. Joseph's University Photographer.

A first attempt to find the missing Bible involved visiting the lower level of Lauinger Library where Woodstock Theological Center Library is now housed, to read the shelf list cards for the rare book collection. Father Henry Bertels, S.J., Woodstock's librarian in the 1970s, made hundreds of meticulous annotations on these cards during his tenure. Nonetheless, the search proved fruitless. A second, and successful, effort involved physically picking up and examining each Bible in the collection that was old enough to have been owned-or used-by Father Greaton, who died at the Jesuit residence at Bohemia Manor in northern Maryland in 1753.

Sure enough, one of the first items checked was a two-volume first edition set of the Catholic Old Testament in English, published in Douai in what is now northern France in 1609-10. Both volumes were rebound in the 19th century by an indifferently talented craftsman; both revealed considerable and lamentable flaws in the paper of their text blocks. But in the second volume-had it been in the first Father Bertels would certainly have found it-was a pasted-in note reading:

Residentiæ Baltimorensi
Ex domo
[probably a misspelling of "dono"]
Rdi. P. Jos: Greaton
Anno Dñi 1752

Residentiæ Sti Josephi
in Baltimore

A search turned up no companion New Testament, hardly surprising given the rarity of editions of the Catholic Bible, or even any part of it, in colonial America. The first Catholic Bible to be printed in America would not appear until 1790.

The route Father Greaton's Bible took to Woodstock is circuitous, and not entirely known. Considered redundant in Baltimore, it was given in 1853 by Father Timothy O'Brien to the then-Jesuit editor, collector, and bibliographer Father Joseph Maria Finotti, who duly recorded the gift in the book itself. But Father Finotti died in 1879 in Colorado, leaving a voluminous library of American Catholic rarities, the basis for his Bibliographica Catholica Americana, published in 1872; his literary executor was the noted Catholic historian John Gilmary Shea. Shea picked out from Finotti's books those he wanted; the rest he consigned to a series of auctions. We know he didn't pick out this admittedly somewhat tattered copy of the Douai Bible, because Shea's library passed intact to Georgetown University following his death in 1892. The Woodstock stamps in the two volumes of the Bible are early, and it's just possible that the books were purchased at the Finotti sales; certainly they entered the Woodstock collection not long after that time.

Search the Library Site

37th and N Streets, N.W., Washington, D.C., 20057 | (202) 687-7452
Georgetown University Library Home Contact Us Georgetown University Library Home Contact Us Home Projects Associates Events Newsletter Giving